Just finished watching Harper’s Island episode 11… although even before watching it, I was feeling sad… I knew beforehand that Chloe an dCal will die in this episode… awww..
How did I know it? Someone commented on a post I made and she asked what song was playing during the death of the two… And some one also answered…
A lot of the characters died today. John Wakefield did a killing spree in their hideaway.. that’s where the cute girl was murdered as well as Jimmy’s buddy, Zane.
I want to qoute someone who just commented that actually has a big possibility of happening..
Ok, I really have no clue. Just guesses. But seriously, considering the last episode that was on, I am going to have to go with my feeling that Jimmy is def. wakefields son, but he is not in on it. Wakefield had the chance to kill both Abby and Jimmy and did not. I don’t think Wakefield is Abby’s father. And I think that the show wants everyone to think Jimmy is in on it. The one question I haven’t been able to solve is why the heck is Wakefield doing this? If it has been all about Abby then why kill people she didn’t even know? Like basically most of the wedding party? Unless, Wakefield was never responcible in the first place for those murders back when Abby’s mom was killed. What if it was the other way around? What if someone else killed those people? And the Sheriff hated Wakefield because Wakefield had an affair with his wife so what if the Sheriff framed Wakefield all those years ago? And that’s why he shot him but didn’t kill him. And thats why Wakefield is gone mad. He was banished from the island, thought dead, and hated and despised and rejected for all those years, blamed for something horrible he never did, and what if thats why he is doing this. He is mad with grief and hatred and he wants to become the monster that everyone accused him of being and he wants the truth to come out. Wouldn’t that be a sick twist?
Alright, what do you think?
Alexa said
July 6 2009 @ 1:42 pm
Just going off of what I know about story structures, with two episodes to go, they do not want to give away the second murderer (because it has been advertised that we won’t know until the finale, it clearly is not Jimmy).
But, Wakefield is the murderer, but I think it is more complex than what we know so far, which I’m sure will be explained soon. I’m sure they put more thought into it than just a guy that went on a killing spree, there had to have been more provoking the deaths.
We need to somehow tie up the last mysteries:
Bag of Money – why was it in that boat? Nobody seems to be missing it or looking for it.
Second Murderer – who would give the audience the greatest shock value? I feel like I’ll be taking a total shot in the dark, but I almost suspect the groom of playing a slightly larger part in it. If we go on the premise that it is ‘all about Abby’, this really leaves us with two surviving people, Jimmy and Henry. Perhaps even, there is no second killer praying on the wedding party, but perhaps the second killer is the person that will kill Wakefield?
Murderer and Madison – what is the special bond here between the two? Madison seems to be the only one with any inside scoop on the murderer, and perhaps even the motive. If we’re to discover who the second murderer is, it will surely be through her.
Wakefield’s Child – I’ve had the long standing suspicion Jimmy was the son of Wakefield, not the second murderer. I also started to be suspicious of Madison as perhaps the child, but that wouldn’t line up for her being the child of Abby’s mother. But, I think this because Wakefield keeps telling Madison that if she cooperates and lies, her father will come back, which is a lie… and I just don’t think that the characters (or the writers) would have made that the motive, had it not been actual.
Suicide Pact – Once again, going on structure, the writers would not have added this unless it was going to go somewhere… the series has been to well put together to let these things slide.
Tarrot Cards and Psychic (events):
Psychic gets bloody nose on Abby’s name.
Madison stole tower card.
Trish is told a man will betray her, but the man will also be her savior. We ultimately have to believe that the only man that can really betray her is Henry. He has not done so yet, so we are waiting for that to happen. Perhaps he gets caught up with Abby, and then saves Trish or sacrifices himself to Wakefield so she can escape.
[Reply]